A daughter is a coparcener by birth, whether or not her father was alive in 2005. The position is settled — but many family arrangements still proceed as if it were not.
The Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 made daughters coparceners in joint family property. For fifteen years afterwards, courts disagreed about who it actually applied to. That question is now settled.
What the amendment did
Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 was substituted so that the daughter of a coparcener becomes, by birth, a coparcener in her own right in the same manner as a son. She has the same rights and the same liabilities in respect of the coparcenary property.
That means an equal share on partition, the right to demand partition at all, and the ability to dispose of her share by will.
The confusion, and how it ended
The dispute was whether the amendment applied where the father had died before 9 September 2005. Prakash v. Phulavati (2015) held that both the father and the daughter had to be alive on that date. Danamma v. Amar (2018) took a different view. The conflict left thousands of matters unresolved.
A three-judge bench settled it in Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma (2020). The court held that the coparcenary right is acquired by birth, so it does not depend on the father being alive on the date of the amendment. A daughter is a coparcener whether her father died before or after 9 September 2005.
The practical limits
Partitions already completed. A partition effected by a registered deed, or by a court decree, before 20 December 2004 is protected. Oral partitions are not ordinarily recognised, precisely to prevent fabricated claims of an earlier division.
Self-acquired property. The coparcenary right attaches to ancestral and joint family property. A father's self-acquired property passes under his will, or on intestacy under Section 8, where daughters in any event inherit equally as Class I heirs.
Claiming a share
Start by establishing the character of the property — ancestral or self-acquired — from the title documents and the revenue records. Then trace the devolution through the generations. If the share is not conceded, a partition suit is filed before the civil court having jurisdiction, seeking a declaration of the share and division by metes and bounds, usually with an injunction to prevent alienation while the suit is pending.
There is no limitation on a coparcener's right to seek partition while she remains a coparcener. But where she has been excluded from possession and that exclusion is open and hostile, delay can create real evidentiary difficulties. Acting promptly is better than relying on the absence of a limitation bar.
This article is general information on the law and is not legal advice. Every matter turns on its own facts.