Both sides must now file a sworn affidavit of assets, income and liabilities. It has changed how maintenance is assessed — and how these cases are won.
In Rajnesh v. Neha (2020) the Supreme Court addressed a problem every family court faced: maintenance was being claimed and resisted on assertions, with neither side putting their actual finances on record.
The court issued binding directions. The most important is that both parties must file an affidavit of disclosure of assets, income and liabilities in every maintenance proceeding, whatever the statute under which it is brought.
What the affidavit must contain
Salary slips or income tax returns for the preceding three years. Bank statements. Details of immovable and movable property. Outstanding loans and liabilities. Details of dependants. Educational qualifications and employment status. For a self-employed person, business accounts and turnover.
Filing a false affidavit has consequences. Courts have treated deliberate suppression of income as both a ground for drawing an adverse inference and as contempt.
How quantum is assessed
There is no formula, but the factors are consistent:
- The status of the parties and the standard of living during the marriage
- The reasonable needs of the claimant and of any children
- The claimant's own income, qualifications and earning capacity
- The income and liabilities of the person paying
- The number of dependants that person is genuinely supporting
Two points come up repeatedly. A spouse who is qualified but voluntarily unemployed is assessed on earning capacity, not on declared income. And a claimant with some independent income is not disentitled — the question is whether that income is sufficient to maintain the standard of living to which she was accustomed.
From which date
The court directed that maintenance be awarded from the date of the application, not from the date of the order. Given how long these matters take, that distinction is often worth a substantial sum in arrears.
Avoiding overlapping orders
Maintenance can be claimed under several statutes at once — Section 144 of the BNSS, Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act, Section 20 of the Domestic Violence Act. The court directed that an applicant disclose all pending proceedings, and that any amount already awarded be adjusted so that there is no duplication.
When an order is not paid
An unpaid maintenance order is enforceable through execution proceedings. The court can attach salary, attach property, and in appropriate cases pass coercive orders against a person who has the means but refuses to pay. The court specifically directed that enforcement applications be decided within six months.
This article is general information on the law and is not legal advice. Every matter turns on its own facts.